News analysis

What does “Inside Deutsche Bank” tell us about its governance?

What does “Inside Deutsche Bank” tell us about its governance

What does “Inside Deutsche Bank” tell us about its governance? 

Deutsche Bank – one of Europe’s largest financial institutions – is back in the news for all too familiar reasons. 

Whistleblowers have leaked over 15 million internal records, including emails, board meeting minutes and compliance reports. Many of them suggest wrongdoing by negligence at best, and by intention at worst, in multiple different areas, ranging from lax anti-money laundering controls to mishandling personal information, to decisions that clearly place revenue over ethics in the hierarchy of importance. There are also incredibly glaring red flags over the handling of finances and records connected to individuals like Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein. 

You can read more about those allegations here, but the big question now is what they say about the bank’s standards of governance, as well as what we can expect next.

Let’s dive in:

1. The temporal context

We must first acknowledge that much of the revelations contained in the whistleblower reports relate to actions and incidents that took place years ago – many in the previous decade. 

The bank itself has been quick to draw attention to that fact in an official response to the investigation, saying: 

“We are a different bank today. Under Christian Sewing’s leadership, Deutsche Bank has gone through a fundamental transformation.”

Sewing has held the role of CEO for just over eight years, and was brought on board during a turbulent period for the bank, amid money laundering scandals, falling profits and struggling share prices. 

Much of the information contained in whistleblower documents concerns happenings before he took the reins (although definitely not all – more on that below). Indeed, the chair of Deutsche’s board, Alexander Wynaendts, has given him unreserved backing, saying, “During my tenure I haven’t seen a single decision from Christian Sewing that I was not comfortable with.”

Dive deeper with a free bite-size lesson

Gain real-world corporate governance insights in just 15 minutes. Unlock instant access to a free, expert-led lesson.

Dive deeper with a free bite-size lesson

Gain real-world corporate governance insights in just 15 minutes. Unlock instant access to a free, expert-led lesson.

2. Some failures happened while the bank was supposed to be in transition.

CEO Christian Sewing’s tenure avoided many elements of alleged wrongdoing contained in the whistleblower reports; some events did overlap with his early years on the job. 

For example, under his leadership, the bank actually planned an expansion of its services to key Russian clients despite concerns raised by internal compliance that to do so would risk facilitating money laundering and other financial crimes. 

The bank has also processed questionable payments that appear to contrast with its own stated corporate goals through the years. In 2020, for example, it processed a payment of €1.5 billion connected to an oil investment, in contradiction to its stated environmental goals. 

Sewing was also briefed on efforts to handle the case of US President Donald Trump’s tax records. Deutsche accidentally sent these records to another client in 2017, before Sewing’s tenure, but the efforts to contain the breach carried into it, to the point that Sewing is alleged to have had direct input into the decision to disclose the breach or not. 

Revelations like this tell us some important things about the leadership culture within Deutsche. Sewing’s arrival was supposed to coincide with a new beginning for the bank, marked by stronger governance and better decision-making. What we’re seeing now is that a difference may have existed between the public narrative and the internal reality. 

We cannot say that this culture has continued through to the present day, but we can argue that the public promises of Deutsche to turn itself around are hollower now, in hindsight. If this prompts more scrutiny from regulators and other stakeholders, it’s understandable.

3. The leak itself is a major governance failure

When we look beyond how old some of the information is, and instead focus on the scale of the revelations, we see another governance nightmare for which Deutsche can say little in defence. 

15 million internal documents now open to public viewing is a massive breach. Combine that with the cohort of journalists across the world who were given planned and structured access, and you’ve got a whistleblower campaign that had more than enough room to breathe and achieve the maximum level of impact. 

It says two very important things about Deutsche’s governance:

  • Its policies and culture around handling sensitive information – who has access and what they can do with it – have some serious flaws. 
  • More importantly, its culture discourages whistleblowers from coming forward internally. A campaign with this level of premeditation demonstrates a serious degree of unease around Deutsche’s past actions, and a lack of faith in any internal channels for reporting them. 

Whistleblowers are always a possibility in business. They and the pathways for them to express their concerns need to be protected. It doesn’t matter if boards and executives view them as a nuisance; their ability to come forward is an important check on corporate power and a cornerstone of good governance. It was entirely absent here. 

What happens to those whistleblowers next is a complex question that involves how much Deutsche knows (or will know after investigating) behind the scenes, not to mention varying whistleblower laws in multiple jurisdictions. 

Ultimately, though, the revelations are out there now. The bank’s main concern will likely be the court of public – and regulatory – opinion.

Has the pattern changed?

Given that much of the investigation shines a light on governance practices from years ago, the big question now is whether those practices have changed. More specifically, has the culture feeding into those practices changed? 

This whistleblower investigation adds more weight to the claim that Deutsche’s leaders have long favoured profit over proper compliance. Sewing came on board in 2018 partly to move the bank away from those years. 

Every single stakeholder will now wonder whether he and Deutsche’s two boards (German companies usually have a management board full of executives alongside a supervisory board full of non-executives) have stuck to the promise of change. If not, then they have to consider the possibility that the same cultural flaws that caused so many nightmares over the last 15-20 years continue to exist. 

New investigations are coming. Some will focus on the scale of the data and whether Deutsche safeguarded it properly. Others will centre on the fact that the whistleblowers handed their information to British and US regulators as well as journalists. They now have the info they need, legally protected, to launch further probes. 

These will likely explain more about the bank’s inner workings and whether it has turned over a new leaf. 

Insights on leadership

Want more insights like this? Sign up for our newsletter and receive weekly insights into the vibrant worlds of corporate governance and business leadership. Stay relevant. Keep informed.

About this author

Dan Byrne MA BA is a journalist, writer, and editor specialising in corporate governance and ESG topics. As the Content Manager at The Corporate Governance Institute, Dan creates engaging, insightful content designed to inform and educate global audiences about the latest developments in corporate governance and sustainability.

With a strong focus on research and analysis, Dan consistently delivers compelling narratives that resonate with industry professionals and stakeholders interested in responsible governance and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.

Tags
  • Deutsche Bank
  • Money laundering
  • Reputational risk
  • Whistleblowers